[Update 2014/06/17: Remove XNA comparison, as it is not fair and relevant]
If you are working with a managed language like C# and you are concerned by performance, you probably know that, even if the Microsoft JIT CLR is quite efficient, It has a significant cost over a pure C++ implementation. If you don't know much about this cost, you have probably heard about a mean cost for managed languages around 15-20%. If you are really concern by this, and depending on the cases, you know that the reality of a calculation-intensive managed application is more often around x2 or even x3 slower than its C++ counterpart. In this post, I'm going to present a micro-benchmark that measure the cost of calling a native Direct3D 11 API from a C# application, using various API, ranging from SharpDX, SlimDX, WindowsCodecPack.
Why this benchmark is important? Well, if you intend like me to build some serious 3D games with a C# managed API (don't troll me on this! ;) ), you need to know exactly what is the cost of calling intensively a native Direct3D API (mainly, the cost of the interop between a managed language and a native API) from a managed language. If your game is GPU bounded, you are unlikely to see any differences here. But if you want to apply lots of effects, with various models, particles, materials, playing with several rendering targets and a heavy deferred rendering technique, you are likely to perform lots of draw calls to the Direct3D API. For a AAA game, those calls could be as high as 3000-7000 draw submissions in instancing scenarios (look at latest great DICE publications in "DirectX 11 Rendering in Battlefield 3" from Johan Andersson). If you are running at 60fps (or lower 30fps), you just have 17ms (or 34ms) per frame to perform your whole rendering. In this short time range, drawing calls can take a significant amount of time, and this is a main reason why multi-threading batching command were introduced in DirectX11. We won't use such a technique here, as we want to evaluate raw calls.
As you are going to see, results are pretty interesting for someone that is concerned by performance and writing C# games (or even efficient tools for a 3D Middleware)